67% rate home diagnostic tests very helpful, compared with just 33% for accuracy, DNV survey finds
The gap between perceived usefulness and performance highlights the importance for medical device manufacturers in building confidence in home healthcare technologies, according to global research involving 12,500 people across 17 countries.
People are twice as likely to describe home diagnostic tests as very helpful than as very accurate, according to new global research from DNV, raising questions about how consumers perceive and experience medical technologies outside traditional healthcare settings.
Among respondents who had used home diagnostic tests, 67% described them as very helpful, compared with just 33% who rated them very accurate. A similar pattern emerged for home medical devices, with 68% rating them as very helpful and 36% as very accurate. These findings reflect consumer perceptions rather than performance of the technologies.
The findings come from DNV's latest report The Trust Mandate for Medical Technologies, based on a survey of 12,500 people across 17 countries.
While the results reflect user perceptions rather than the actual accuracy or performance of medical devices, they raise important questions about how people experience, understand and place confidence in technologies they use to manage their health.
Key findings from DNV's research:
- 67% of home diagnostic test users rated them very helpful, compared with 33% who rated them very accurate.
- 68% of home medical device users rated them very helpful, compared with 36% who rated them very accurate.
- 68% of respondents agreed that independent inspections and certifications significantly improve their confidence in the quality and safety of medical technologies.
- 74% believed independent testing significantly improves the safety of new healthcare technologies.
As more medical technologies move into people’s homes, the experience of operating a device and understanding the information it provides becomes particularly important. For manufacturers, this places greater emphasis on understanding the circumstances in which devices are used, particularly when patients may be unfamiliar with medical terminology, uncertain about interpreting results or unsure when to seek professional advice.
Cecilie Gudesen Torp, Managing Director of Medical Technologies, Life Sciences at DNV said:
“Medical technologies have long played a vital role in healthcare. What is changing is how they are used and the role they play in people's everyday lives. For manufacturers, demonstrating safety and performance remains fundamental, but our research highlights another important dimension: how people perceive and place confidence in these technologies. The difference between perceived usefulness and perceived accuracy reminds us that technical performance and public confidence are not necessarily the same thing. As medical technologies take on a greater role in everyday care, understanding both will be increasingly important to building lasting trust.”
Independent assessment plays a role in confidence in medical technology
Beyond users’ direct experiences, the research also explores the factors that influence people's confidence in medical technologies, including reliable results, clinical evidence, healthcare professional recommendations and independent assessment.
More than two thirds of respondents (68%) agreed that independent inspections and certifications significantly improve their confidence in the quality and safety of medical technologies. Nearly three quarters (74%) believe independent testing significantly improves the safety of new healthcare technologies.
These findings point to the importance respondents place on independent scrutiny, alongside factors such as reliable results, clinical evidence and recommendations from healthcare professionals.
Under the European Union's Medical Device Regulation (MDR) and In Vitro Diagnostic Medical Devices Regulation (IVDR), designated Notified Bodies carry out independent conformity assessments for devices requiring their involvement, evaluating compliance with applicable regulatory requirements for safety and performance.
DNV's The Trust Mandate for Medical Technologies examines how people perceive the usefulness, accuracy and safety of medical technologies, and the different factors that contribute to trust.